How do Angi leads work for contractors?
A homeowner describes a job on Angi, and Angi passes the request to contractors who cover that service and area. You pay for the leads you receive, and the price depends on the trade, the job and your area. A homeowner can be matched with more than one pro, so you may be one of several contractors calling about the same job within minutes. HomeAdvisor is part of Angi, so its pro leads work in a similar way. Pricing, refund rules and lead credits change, so read Angi’s current terms for pros before you sign up.
How does Thumbtack charge pros?
On Thumbtack you set up a profile with your services, area and budget. When a customer contacts you or Thumbtack matches you to their request, you pay for that lead, whether or not it becomes a job. The cost depends on the service and local demand. Other pros can be contacted about the same request, so price and speed matter. Thumbtack shows its current pricing to pros inside the app, and it changes, so check it there.
When Angi or Thumbtack makes sense
When you are new in an area with no Google reviews yet, when your schedule has gaps this month, or when you can answer leads within a few minutes during the day. They also suit jobs with a clear scope that you can price over the phone. Keep a simple sheet of every lead you pay for: what it cost, whether you spoke to the homeowner, and whether it became a job. After a month you will know your real cost per job, which is the number that matters, not the cost per lead.
When your own website and Google profile win
Your own site and Google Business Profile show up when people search for your trade and town, like “roofer Ocala” or “septic pumping Lake City”. Those calls are yours alone. You pay for the site once, the profile is free, and both keep working whether or not you top up a lead budget. Every Google review you collect makes the next call easier to win, and that is something a lead platform never gives back to you.
What we’d check first
When we look at contractors who rely on lead apps, the same gaps keep coming up. There is no website at all, so a homeowner who searches the business name after an Angi or Thumbtack match finds only the app profile. The Google Business Profile is missing, unverified, or lists a cell number that goes to a full voicemail. The business email is a free address with no website behind it, which looks less established. And there is no record of which paid leads became jobs. Fixing those four things often brings in more work than raising the lead budget.
How to use both without wasting money
Put your website link and Google review link on your app profiles, truck, yard signs and invoices. Ask every happy customer for a Google review, including the ones who found you on Angi or Thumbtack. Set a monthly cap on paid leads and pause them when your schedule is full. As more calls come in direct, spend less on shared leads and more on your own Google and Facebook ads, where every enquiry goes only to you.
