Guide

Angi, Thumbtack or your own website: which brings contractors more jobs?

Angi and Thumbtack can fill a quiet month, but you pay for each lead and the same homeowner is often sent to other contractors too, so the fastest reply wins. Your own website and Google Business Profile bring calls that go only to you, with no fee per lead. Most contractors do best using both. ExtraMiles builds that website for $99 or $199, paid once.

Updated 2026-11-13 · ExtraMiles

  • $99 or $199, paid once
  • Live preview in 48 hours
  • No monthly fees
  • Pay only if you like it
Not on WhatsApp? Request your preview with a 30-second form

How do Angi leads work for contractors?

A homeowner describes a job on Angi, and Angi passes the request to contractors who cover that service and area. You pay for the leads you receive, and the price depends on the trade, the job and your area. A homeowner can be matched with more than one pro, so you may be one of several contractors calling about the same job within minutes. HomeAdvisor is part of Angi, so its pro leads work in a similar way. Pricing, refund rules and lead credits change, so read Angi’s current terms for pros before you sign up.

How does Thumbtack charge pros?

On Thumbtack you set up a profile with your services, area and budget. When a customer contacts you or Thumbtack matches you to their request, you pay for that lead, whether or not it becomes a job. The cost depends on the service and local demand. Other pros can be contacted about the same request, so price and speed matter. Thumbtack shows its current pricing to pros inside the app, and it changes, so check it there.

Why shared leads turn into a race

When three or four contractors get the same request, the homeowner usually books the first one who calls with a clear answer, or the cheapest. That pushes you to stop work and phone back at once, and it pulls quotes down. It is the biggest difference from a call that comes from your own website, your Google profile or your own ads: that homeowner picked you, and nobody else got their number.

When Angi or Thumbtack makes sense

When you are new in an area with no Google reviews yet, when your schedule has gaps this month, or when you can answer leads within a few minutes during the day. They also suit jobs with a clear scope that you can price over the phone. Keep a simple sheet of every lead you pay for: what it cost, whether you spoke to the homeowner, and whether it became a job. After a month you will know your real cost per job, which is the number that matters, not the cost per lead.

When your own website and Google profile win

Your own site and Google Business Profile show up when people search for your trade and town, like “roofer Ocala” or “septic pumping Lake City”. Those calls are yours alone. You pay for the site once, the profile is free, and both keep working whether or not you top up a lead budget. Every Google review you collect makes the next call easier to win, and that is something a lead platform never gives back to you.

What we’d check first

When we look at contractors who rely on lead apps, the same gaps keep coming up. There is no website at all, so a homeowner who searches the business name after an Angi or Thumbtack match finds only the app profile. The Google Business Profile is missing, unverified, or lists a cell number that goes to a full voicemail. The business email is a free address with no website behind it, which looks less established. And there is no record of which paid leads became jobs. Fixing those four things often brings in more work than raising the lead budget.

How to use both without wasting money

Put your website link and Google review link on your app profiles, truck, yard signs and invoices. Ask every happy customer for a Google review, including the ones who found you on Angi or Thumbtack. Set a monthly cap on paid leads and pause them when your schedule is full. As more calls come in direct, spend less on shared leads and more on your own Google and Facebook ads, where every enquiry goes only to you.

Free, no obligation

See your new website before you spend a cent

  1. 1We build your site with your name, services, towns and license number.
  2. 2You get a live preview link by text or email within 48 hours.
  3. 3Like it? Pay $99 or $199 once and it goes live. Don’t? You owe nothing.

No credit card. No contract. We never share your number.

Get my free preview

Takes 30 seconds.

By sending, you agree we may text or call you about your preview. See our privacy policy.

What you get

What ExtraMiles costs

    Want calls on top of the website? ExtraMiles also runs Facebook, Instagram and Google ads for your service area on three plans, Lead Engine, Growth Engine and Scale Engine, each with a written month-1 lead target and quoted on a free strategy call.

    See the lead plans

    Digital Business Card

    $99 one-time

    • 1-page mobile website
    • Tap-to-call and contact form
    • Google Maps location
    • Your own domain, hosting and SSL for year one
    Preview it free

    Lead Generator

    $199 one-time

    • Up to 3 pages, one per service
    • Tap-to-call and tap-to-WhatsApp
    • 2 professional emails (estimates@yourcompany.com)
    • Local on-page SEO for your service area
    Preview it free

    How it works

    Preview first, pay after. No monthly fees.

    1. 1

      Send your details

      Your business name, trade, town and phone. Two minutes on WhatsApp.

    2. 2

      See your preview

      We build your site and send you a live link within 48 hours.

    3. 3

      Approve, then pay

      Like it? Pay once and it goes live on your domain. Don’t like it? You owe nothing.

    FAQ

    Questions contractors ask us

    Is Angi worth it for contractors?

    It can be when you need work quickly and can call back fast, but you pay per lead and leads can be shared with other pros. Track your cost per booked job over a month before you spend more, and check Angi’s current terms.

    Is Thumbtack worth it for contractors?

    For some trades and areas, yes, especially while you build reviews. You pay for leads whether or not they become jobs, so set a budget, reply quickly and compare the cost per job with calls from your own site and Google profile.

    Are Angi and Thumbtack leads shared?

    Often, yes. A homeowner can be matched with or contact several pros for the same job. Calls from your own website, Google Business Profile or your own ads go only to you.

    Do I need a website if I’m on Angi or Thumbtack?

    It helps. Many homeowners search your business name before they book, and a website with your license, photos and service area makes you look established. ExtraMiles builds one for $99 or $199, paid once, with no monthly fees.

    What is the cheapest way to get contractor leads without paying per lead?

    A verified Google Business Profile with real photos, your service area and reviews, plus a simple mobile website with a tap-to-call button. Both bring calls that go only to you.

    Can ExtraMiles run ads instead of buying shared leads?

    Yes. ExtraMiles runs Google and Facebook ads for contractors from your own ad account, so every enquiry goes only to you. Lead plans are quoted on a free call, plus ad budget paid to the platform.

    Your free preview is one message away

    Send your business name and town. We build it, you decide after you see it.

    Or request it with the 30-second form